Story:
REWEAVING CORPORATE DNA: BUILDING A CULTURE OF DESIGN THINKING AT CITRIX
In 2009, Citrix CEO Mark Templeton issued a challenge: Make Citrix a leader of design excellence by transforming the traditional engineering-driven company into one whose very DNA is built on the fundamentals of design thinking and doing.
I accepted Mark’s challenge as the company’s new design leader and, in the years since, have built a robust—and still growing—design function chartered with making this vision of design leadership a reality.
I’m Catherine Courage, and this is the story of my company’s journey—a journey that has, in just a few years, seen the transformation of one of Silicon Valley’s most successful technology firms into a leader of design-driven excellence and innovation.
Citrix is the cloud company that enables mobile workstyles—empowering people to work and collaborate from anywhere, securely accessing apps and data on any of the latest devices, as easily as they would in their own office.
Citrix products are in use at more than 260,000 organizations and by over 100 million users globally. Citrix customers include the world’s largest Internet companies, 99 percent of Fortune Global 500 enterprises, and hundreds of thousands of small- to mid-size businesses worldwide.
Citrix was founded in 1989 and went IPO on December 8, 1995. Annual revenue in 2012 was $2.59 billion.
Citrix employs nearly 8,000 people in nearly 50 locations worldwide, with strong presence in the Americas, EMEA and Asia-Pacific, and dual headquarters in Fort Lauderdale, FL and Silicon Valley.
Our CEO Mark believed that, in addition to traditional means of growth, his company’s success in exceeding the $2 billion mark would depend heavily on its ability to focus on improving the end-to-end user experience of its products, services, and partnerships.
Mark also knew that such a dramatic shift wouldn’t happen overnight, but would require strong leadership to build a rock-star design presence capable of propelling the company forward toward this goal.
As for me, I found the answer to this company-wide challenge at the Stanford d-school. After completing the school’s Customer-Focused Innovation program in 2009, I knew I had found the key to unlocking the creative potential at Citrix: design thinking. Design thinking is an approach to innovation that can be applied to all areas of business. Design thinking does not refer to a formal step-by-step process, but to a framework and a mindset. It is focused on a bias towards action, a human-centered viewpoint and a mode of continual experimentation. The core idea is that by deeply understanding customer needs, opportunities for innovation will emerge. These ideas can be further refined through rapid prototypes and iterations to result in breakthrough outcomes.
I now had the language and direction I needed to infuse design thinking into other business and leadership functions in the company. Creativity is the key to invention and ultimate success. My task was to harness the creative capability of Citrix employees through the development of design thinking leaders, who could then bring our renewed focus on innovation to life.
Originally tasked with a tactical and strategic design charter, my mandate grew considerably as the company came to recognize just how impactful a company-wide design focus is to the company’s success.
I now lead the newly formed Customer Experience organization as Senior Vice President, reporting directly to the CEO. My team works to empower all divisions of the company, from executives to individual contributors, to make innovation and customer focus central to their thinking. Our goal is to equip an entire organization with 21st century leadership skills: from curiosity to a bias toward action and experimentation to the ability to collaborate across boundaries. We believe that these are the leadership skills that will drive innovation across the business.
Often referred to as a “center of excellence” for design-driven innovation, this new organization brings design thinking and doing to the highest levels of executive leadership at Citrix. We consider everyone at the company an active contributor in creating exceptional experiences for customers and partners, both inside and outside the company. At Citrix, everyone can be a design leader.
TIMELINE
2010 – Executive Support and Grassroots Excitement
Strong focus on executive engagement – Executives from across the organization were sent to the Stanford d.school to learn and embrace the key elements of design thinking. Executives were asked not so much to dictate this new approach to employees, but to champion, encourage, and support projects that were taking this approach. Executive support helped generate the much-needed enthusiasm and interest in design thinking that was key to the momentum of the internal adoption of the idea. Today we have built an in-house catalyst and training program, which I describe below. But we still leverage the d.school to train selected executive across the company, giving them a valuable n external perspective, and helping them learn the power and language of design thinking.
Provide employees a basic understanding of design principles –We knew we could not create design leaders everywhere overnight, and we did not want to drive a mandate. We wanted to start by making design into something people could relate to, and wanted to learn more about. We started by working to give employees a basic understanding of the principles of design thinking.
Laying out our five core design principles, as relevant today as when they were first articulated, was a crucial first step in making design thinking relatable to everyone across the company. This video is one example of how we convey these to employees, in a manner anyone can understand and related to: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJT340fooKA
The five principles are:
· Focus on users: Who is your customer? We all have a customer… whether they are internal or external… it’s your job to meet their needs.
· Make it simple: Do the hard work, so your users don’t have to. Customers will eagerly adopt products and processes that make doing their job easy.
· Inspire delight: Exceed your user’s expectations. We want people to actually enjoy - even love – their every experience with all things Citrix.
· Exhibit craftsmanship: Attend to fit and finish, and take pride in the quality of your work.
· Deliver unique value: We can all be innovators. We want to do things in new and better ways. Citrix stands for excellence, not the status quo.
An important step was exposing employees to these principles wherever possible. Every new Citrix hire learns about them on his or her first day at work. We’ve created posters, a handbook, and a website with examples and stories to make the principles relatable to all employees. We featured them at a global employee meeting. We even created a badge card listing them – and thousands of employees wear this card today, along with their corporate ID.
2011 – Creative Space and Support to Make Real Change Happen
Build an awesome creative space – Inspired by the d.school’s open, collaborative design space, I knew that creating a culture of innovation and driving behavioral change at Citrix would require a radically new approach to the way work happens. To accomplish this, I championed a project to build a collaborative design studio at our Silicon Valley headquarters.
The design studio provides 2000 sq. ft. of open space where team members from multiple disciplines come together to share ideas, iterate, and innovate. Everything in the space—tables, whiteboards, comfy chairs and couches—is modular and completely customizable, allowing teams to adapt on the fly, and shape their workflows in real time as work happens.
The space is low-tech by design, filled with markers, sticky notes, and every quick-and-dirty prototype material under the sun—from construction paper to pipe cleaners. It’s also intentionally designed to be unbook-able, since no one can “schedule” innovation. The casualness of the space puts people in the right frame of mind to go outside of their traditional comfort zones and build stronger relationships with teammates. Even the most analytical team members can't help but sketch their thoughts and ideas on the table whiteboards while they sit and chat.
The design studio is an example of how a nontraditional workspace can foster collaboration, enable new modes of communication, and improve the quality of the products we produce for customers. Instead of preaching the merits of collaboration and working across teams, it just started happening. Teams that were typically “collaborating” in cubes via email and instant message were now emerging from their cubes and meeting in the design space to truly collaborate. They would leave their computers behind and gather around a whiteboard to ideate and draw concepts. People were ideating, prototyping and experimenting without being told because the space fostered the right behavior. The employees were leading the change to design thinking. They were the leaders.
Since the opening of our first space, six additional design spaces have opened at Citrix offices around the globe, with three more scheduled to open soon. This demonstrates the company's fiscal and strategic commitment to design thinking. But note too that it has been employees who’ve demanded that these spaces be built. People who had the opportunity to work in one of these space immediately saw their value, and, self-motivated, led the charge to create one in their locale. Another great example of design leadership emerging via experiences rather than mandates.
These spaces have had such an impact, not just for the design team, but for teams across the company. It is regularly used by groups such as IT, HR and Finance. We never would have imagined this when first brought the concept to life. An added bonus is that this initiative helps further the broader WorkAnywhere effort, aimed at making all our offices better-suited to collaboration and flexible workstyles. This video highlights WorkAnywhere: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkxYUt8isiY
Supporting real change – Last year, I asked Julie Baher to direct a new Business Design team, to foster collaboration with all divisions across the company (Sales, Human Resources, Legal, Operations, IT, etc.) as part of a series of strategic initiatives, and to develop exceptional experiences for customers, partners, and employees. This would be a critical mechanism for developing leaders across the organization.
Julie and the new Business Design team took on a charter to infuse design thinking into the organization from multiple directions:
· Top-down – By continuing to send VP’s and key business unit GM’s to the Stanford programs, so they would understand the language and toolset of design thinking, gain an external perspective on their work, and be motivated to support design thinking initiatives.
· Sideways – By holding design thinking workshops for mid-level managers and mid-career individual contributors, empowering them with a means of tackling key challenges.
· Bottom-up – By leveraging various employee touchpoints - such as global all-org meetings, the company intranet, and new hire training – to disseminate key messages about what it means to have a design thinking approach. To the same end, the business design team also provides dedicated project support to a wide variety of partners, across the company.
None of these program or initiatives was mandated or required. We wanted to attract people who see value in what we’re doing, or have an intrinsic interest in it. We knew these people would be the real leaders. And to date, all our classes and workshops are oversubscribed, and we couldn’t possibly accept every offer to collaborate. Our goal is to teach people to fish. We want to spread the expertise and the design leadership skills across the company, so those new leaders can teach their teams. So far this approach has been a great success!
The team also engaged design firm IDEO to help scale the impact of design thinking at Citrix. In conjunction with the Customer Experience team, they drove a significant design thinking initiative to reinvent how the company on-boards customers. We wanted to share a real Citrix success story early, so people could see the value of the design thinking approach. By leveraging outside support, we could get an early success that could be shared while we were developing our own design leaders internally, who would then tackle the next set of challenges.
In addition, a new design-thinking branding effort was underway. Spearheaded by Uday Gajendar and Andrew Day, the “Design Matters to Me” program brought employees news from within Citrix and the wider design community. The program gave employees insight into how to apply design principles into their everyday jobs, by using real examples of design in action from across the company. We also brought in outside speakers to share their stories of success through investing in design. We also highlighted the “best of” each quarter by awarding “Design Hero” awards to people who demonstrated design leadership and went above and beyond to drive change with design thinking. These stories helped make the impact of design thinking real and relatable. The Design Matters program soon became the ‘brand’ of the design-thinking movement at Citrix and is still an important element today.
2012 – Connect and Kickoff
Citrix Connect, the company’s annual engineering summit
The Business Design team was given the chance to redesign Connect, the company’s annual engineering summit. Held in five locations across the world— London, Bangalore Santa Clara, Santa Barbara, and Ft. Lauderdale—it was a huge opportunity for the team to evangelize and teach design thinking leadership and skills to more than 2,000 engineers at Citrix.
Julie and the Business Design team worked with a boutique agency – LIME Design – to develop a design-thinking strategy for the five-city, three-continent program. Attendees completed an interactive group experience that applied design thinking to solving real business challenges, building low-fidelity prototypes, and testing their solutions. Teams also participated in a crowd-sourced brainstorm experience, generating numerous ideas on how to improve the engineering organization. It was a wild success and was highlighted by employees as inspirational and the best part of the event. Also, many of these ideas have been put into place.
Citrix Sales Kickoff
Building on their success at Connect, the Business Design team was then asked to design a similar integrative experience for the company’s annual Sales Kickoff events in Orlando and Singapore. The goal: help more than 300 sales leaders learn to use design thinking to take a more creative, analytical, and collaborative approaches to key business problems.
The outcome: a six-month Sales Leadership Innovation Challenge. Sales leaders from across the globe volunteered to participate in a competition to develop solutions to sales challenges, using a design thinking approach. This upshot was a set of solutions that are currently being implemented to drive the sales business forward.
This was not just a success for the sales organization, but a great example of distributed design thinking, as teams collaborated despite being spread around the globe. This is not an easy task, but is one that is a reality of today’s global and mobile workforce. As a company that promotes mobility and creates remote collaboration products, it is critical for us to embrace this reality. What we have found in the instance of the sales project and others is that there are critical paces where it is key to bring the primary stakeholders together…. such as at the kickoff of a project. The power of having face time with teammates to build a team connection, establish goals and ideate in the beginning of a project, is key. When you set this foundation, you find it much easier to working across the globe, collaborating remotely using video, screen sharing and remote sketching.
2013 – Catalysts, Education, and Ambient Design
Citrix Design Catalysts program
The Citrix Design Catalysts are a group of more than 100 individual contributors and managers who've done an intensive, three-day internal Citrix design thinking “bootcamp.” This is one of the most important elements of developing design leadership across the company. The goal: enabling these leaders to drive design thinking-focused change projects within their organizations. As they do this, Catalysts get critical support from the Business Design team, which provides them with both hands-on assistance and a variety of tools and resources, such as a Facilitator’s Guide and Design Thinking Checklist.
Anyone can raise his or her hand to be a catalyst. We provide education and support and in return we ask that these new design leaders bring design thinking back to their organizations by spreading awareness and understanding of the approach, but also by tacking real problems . Today throughout the company, in every organization and at every level, Design Catalysts are taking the lead in transforming the way the company works, to focus on giving every user a great experience with Citrix, every time.
Setting the Stage for Success
Design innovations are meaningful only if they are implemented. Perhaps naively, we did not realize that this would in fact be the hardest part of the journey…turning design thinking into real results. We have done a variety of things to ensure the success of our new design leaders.
Day Two of the business design team’s bootcamp targets implementation head-on: Participants craft an execution plan around a design challenge from their everyday responsibilities. They explore how their project benefits Citrix and Citrix' customers. They create a journey map of the current landscape, noting any current customer pain points and to uncover how needs are served today. As part of the plan, they also create a core team, extended team and identify SME's who they would need to engage. Every project must also have a clear executive sponsor. The plan also shapes their empathy work by identifying analogous and extreme users to target. They end the day with a commitment to taking that crucial first step.
For some, after leaving a workshop they have all the tools they need to run a project. In those cases, we may do "coaching" and periodically check-in with them or give them tips on how to run a brainstorm or test an idea. For other projects, the business design team will facilitate a "design kickoff" and lead the team through 1-3 days of empathy and ideation. In this model, the team then takes the ideas and prototypes, develops them further and works to implement. The most intense engagements are where the business designers work for 6 weeks to 6 months with a team on wicked problems. In this case, the empathy work may involve several weeks of interviews and visits in multiple locations. Depending on the problem space, prototyping may be more technical and require more than paper and pen! The longer engagements tend to be projects that run across multiple business units or divisions and are directly challenges to the status quo. These require more "selling" of the project, the empathy findings, the ideas to the business and stakeholders so that everyone keeps aligned and the project team has executive supporters who are removing any roadblocks. We learned from experience that forging a new way of working takes a lot of grit, so having a strong ecosystem of support is key.
In longer engagements, the business design team is “embedded” during execution phase, checking in with the implementation team on a regular cadence to ensure ideas are implemented or the implementation workarounds are aligned with identified design principles. Business Designers' presence as an extended team member during the implementation phase is one of the ways to ensure ideas are being executed.
Examples of success include:
1) A better learning experience for customers – The Citrix Education team partnered with the Business Design team to launch an initiative to improve the experience of learning about and mastering/deploying Citrix products. Intensive user research yielded several key insights, all around the need to make courses and presentation more relevant to real-world student needs, and to support the ultimate goal of getting to, and maintaining, a successful product deployment.
These insights led the team to make a series of strategic changes both in course offerings, and ways it engages learners. Courses were redesigned to include more hands-on exercises, and case study material, making them more engaging and relevant to student needs. Selected course content was also revised to address the needs of system architects, who are key influencers and stakeholders in strategic product deployments. The team leveraged both Citrix and outside expertise to create "student resource kits" for attendees to access once they're back at work. These kits provide both help in applying what they've learned, and insights on material not covered in class. Also forthcoming are new online modularized classes, enabling students to focus on tasks and topics directly relevant to their needs and jobs, without spending time on those that aren't.
2) Using product data to improve customer’s support experience – Citrix support staff and customers have an enormous range of knowledge about our products, how they can best be set up and managed, and how to fix them when problems arise. But support personnel didn’t always have all this knowledge at their disposal, to assist customers looking for help. Enthused by his design thinking training, Support Managing Director Mike Stringer looked at customer feedback and had an inspiration: Why not leverage existing log file data to help users better configure our products to avoid problems, then quickly solve them when they arise? Mike and his team quickly moved from prototyping to testing, to iterating based on user input. The upshot: Citrix AutoSupport, which gives users reliable, targeted information on how to tune and fix problems with their virtualization installations. AutoSupport shows how listening to, and working with, customers can help companies move quickly from ideas to useful solutions.
3) Compliance training workshop redesign – No one likes to do the legal compliance training required at most corporations. But the Citrix Legal team isn’t satisfied with forcing folks to do dull interactive exercises and read stultifying compliance guidelines. To improve employees’ knowledge of job-critical compliance standards, Legal put on their design leadership hat and used empathy to realize it needs employees to pay better attention to this training – and that means making the training much more relevant and engaging. Led by Senior Director Peter Connor, the Legal department partnered with the Business Design team to host a design thinking workshop. The participants did in-depth interviews and ideation sessions with employees, to learn about current pain points and find out how they’d like to engage around the topics of risk and compliance. Many prototypes and ideas were tested and vetted. From that, a new compliance “journey” was created that is in the process of being rolled out. In the new approach, employees who take the basic courses are able to re-certify in subsequent years, rather than mindlessly repeating the same course. Employees in higher risk positions take a more customized track. The courses themselves were updated with actual case studies and relevant scenarios. By streamlining the course rollout process, the reminders sent to employees and tailoring the courses, we estimate a savings of 3600 hours of employee time in 2013 and over 9000 hours in 2014! If time is money, then a conservative estimate is ~$3 million over the first four years of savings.
Increased Investment in Design thinking Education
We’ve also recently brought on a new Director of Education, Diana Joseph, whose sole role is to spread design thinking boot camps within the company, in order to further establish leaders among employees.
In addition, we’re offering a course called “Design Thinking for Managers.” The course addresses the unique challenges of managing teams at Citrix. The idea is to help managers leverage and support the innovation and creativity of their teams.
The class presents clear ways for managers become design leaders by accelerating creativity & innovation through:
· Rewards – highlighting team members who try new things through a new “culture of experimentation” strategy
· Recognition – creating “team heroes” who reach out to customers, empathize with their issues, and create novel solutions
· Environment – creating new spaces in the office that allow for flexible working and innovation, such as small design studios
Design is Everywhere: Ambient Design
As design thinking continues to gain momentum, one of the challenges facing the program is providing the tools and space employees need, wherever those employees might be working at the moment. This is the idea behind ambient design thinking.
One of the best examples of ambient design thinking is the Business Design team’s recently launched “pop-up studio” program. Each is set up for a short time in an common space, such as a cafeteria, with designers gathering input from coworkers on reshaping key elements of the Citrix employee experience. Informal and relaxed, these popups have been both well attended and amazingly generative. Early sessions have produced great insights and suggestions on the design of new onboarding procedures, improving learning and development offerings to employees, reconfiguring café spaces to encourage collaboration, and more. With groups throughout the company following up on these and other contributions, several organizations, including HR and Corporate Citizenship, have signed up to partner in future pop-ups, hoping to gather vital input for their own initiatives. Here’s a time-lapsed video of a pop-up in action: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SQqeNRi8h8
At Citrix, we use a set of “busted” myths to dispel common misconceptions about design thinking which our Lead Business Designer, Rachana Rele, drew from our initial engagements with employees. Change can be hard and sometimes people can have a kneejerk reaction and resist it. We wanted to arm our new design leaders with responses to some of the resistance we knew they might face when spreading design thinking to their part of the organization. These myths have also made many design leaders in the making realize, “I can do that! I want to be a design leader.”
Myth 1 – Design thinking is only for “design” projects
Design thinking is when you create a thoughtful experience in every customer interaction before, during, and after using your product or service. Everyone at Citrix has a customer, whether another employee, a Citrix partner, an external customer, or an end-user. For any project, starting with empathy is the key to generating ideas and prototyping solutions.
Myth 2. Design thinking is someone else’s job
Creating thoughtful experiences for customers is everyone’s job. Design thinking provides a set of tools and mindsets to embrace customer-centric product- or service-development.
Myth 3. Design thinking takes too long
Design thinking brings a focus on the end-customer and mindsets around collaboration, iteration, and experimentation. Like Agile programming approaches, design thinking actually gives you shorter cycles and quick feedback and iteration loops. Ultimately this helps you build the right solution.
Myth 4. Design thinking is easier said than done
Design Thinking has been applied to real-world problems and situations at Citrix. Projects in areas such as legal sales onboarding and HR recruiting are underway to revamp customer and employee experiences.
Myth 5. Design thinking is just a process
Yes, Design thinking is a process. But more importantly, it is a mindset. This mindset includes these core tenets:
· Bias toward action – taking small concrete steps to move your project one step forward
· Learner’s mindset – accepting that the first solution is rarely (if ever) the right solution, and that innovation requires iteration
· Encouraging disparate viewpoints – getting a holistic perspective on problems and solutions
1. Almost 4000 employees have participated in a form of hands-on design training.
2. The Business Design team embeds their innovation leaders into live projects. We advise project managers throughout the company on their implementations of design thinking, and consider this ongoing list of projects a measure of success, so far serving more than a dozen major departments (Product, Finance, HR, Sales, Legal, Customer Marketing, etc.) on more than 50 projects, ranging from workspace design to process re-invention. The momentum and call for support has been purely viral with leaders with a design vision reaching out to us for support.
3. Overwhelming demand for classes. We measure success, in part, by knowing we have a constant list of employees who are hoping to attend internal and Stanford d.school classes to learn more about design thinking. We currently have 250 people scheduled for internal design classes (after adding two courses to meet demand) and still have 35 people on the waiting list.
4. Nearly 120 people are designated as Catalysts. They have invested a minimum of two full days in innovation training and act as ambassadors to the business. They live within different functions across the company, which helps spread the power of design thinking.
5. Citrix products have won more than 20 award since we adopted a design approach, showing the strength of Citrix products influenced by new ways of designing.
6. Return on Investment for the business. Whether it is a new product that is being launched or an internal process that has been revamped. We are starting to calculating ROIs in the millions across projects.
7. News articles in top tier business publications in which Citrix is positioned as a thought leader describing the success of design thinking.
· Forbes: Most Innovative Companies: - 08/2013 - http://www.forbes.com/companies/citrix-systems/
· Forbes: Meet 10 Rising Stars At The World's Most Innovative Companies – 08/2013 - http://www.forbes.com/sites/samanthasharf/2013/08/14/meet-10-rising-stars-at-the-worlds-most-innovative-companies/
· Interiors and Sources – 05/03/2013 – The Server Room at Citrix by Robert Niemenan
· Silicon Valley Business Journal – 04/05/2013 – Meet Silicon Valley’s Most Influential Women (Catherine Courage)
· The Wall Street Journal – 04/24/2012 – Doodling for Dollars By Rachel Emma Silverman
· The Wall Street Journal – 06/06/2012 – More Schools Set Their Minds on Design Thinking By Melisa Korn and Rachel Emma Silverman
· Investors.com – 07/17/2012 – Products in Action Reveal Your Next Innovative Leap By Amy Alexander
· VMBlog – 12/3/2011 - Citrix: 2012 - The Year of Emotionally Resonant Simplicity by Uday Gajendar
· Harvard Business Review – 11/21/2011 - Inventing the Collaborative Workspace by Adam Richardson
8. Citrix continues to invest in design. I now report directly to the CEO, elevating design to the highest circles of executive leadership. In addition, the Business Design team now has nine full-time team members—up from its original three in 2012—and continues to grow. The majority of the power of the program comes from the employees and their interest in taking the tools and knowledge and driving the program. The small, nimble Business Design team provides education and mentorship, and facilitates this process.
9. Citrix is a role model for design for other companies. For example, after an Adobe employee shadowed a Citrix innovation workshop, the company began running pilot courses for their customer service organization. Adobe Customer Service Design teams now attend design-thinking training as a matter of course.
We also receive an average of two requests per months from other companies who have heard our design-thinking story and want to come visit our site and learn from our journey. We happily accommodate these requests. We’ve had companies from as far as Sweden and Australia come to visit in-person.
We also influence local Silicon Valley startups through a program developed by Uday Gajendar for the Citrix Startup Accelerator program, providing training and support to innovators.
10. We are now at a place in time where design thinking has permeated the culture. And we believe it is a unique and critical differentiator for Citrix.
As a result, design thinking will soon be a new Citrix leadership blueprint competency. This blueprint is the set of competencies that all employees measure themselves against as a part of their annual review.
11. Stanford’s Hasso Plattner Institute selected Citrix as a partner in cutting edge research on evaluation tools for innovation. Read about it here: http://dschool.stanford.edu/blog/2010/09/17/dschool-launches-2-new-lines-of-dsearch/
The team has learned a lot in the last few years.
1. Don’t go it alone. Instead, seek out experts, learn from them, and partner with them. And share your experiences in return. Learn from outside leaders.
2. You’ll find design leaders in the making in unexpected places. Be creative in using design thinking to connect employees with one another, wherever they might be. Touch and track every major business and operational function at your company, to guarantee that design and innovation are both pervasive and persuasive elements of your business.
3. Have empathy within your company. Some groups will get design thinking right away and others will take longer. Don’t assume it will be an instant learning experience for all. Have patience and put yourself in the shoes of others who have never experience this approach to problem solving.
4. Executive support is critical in fostering and developing leadership. Being a pioneer of change can feel risky and uncomfortable. We don’t need our executives to develop the solutions or drive the changes, but their words of encouragement give teams “permission to innovate.” Executive support when you are developing your pioneer design leaders is key.
5. Remember: It’s a journey, not a destination. Culture change and leadership development is an ongoing process of evolution and revolution. Be flexible and adjust as the company responds to new ideas.
Thanks to Mark Templeton, Gordon Payne, Julie Baher, Uday Gajendar, Andrew Day, Diana Joseph, Mike Maass, Rachana Rele, Meg Lee Weir, Stacy St. Louis and countless other “design catalysts” across the company. Also Lime Design, Stanford d.school and IDEO for helping extend the reach and impact of design at Citrix.
This is a great example of a human-centered blueprint for organizational change. The combination of executive champions and grassroots change makers is powerful. Dedicating a space for innovation sends a message that design is important and part of the everyday work of changing culture.
- Log in to post comments
Thanks Maureen. It's definitely been a great combination of bottoms up initiative with support from the top.
- Log in to post comments
Insightful article of the changing focus of innovative companies.
A couple of things stood out for me:
Support from the top down.
-to create real change it has to be supported from the top down.
A Learner's Mindset.
-keeping an open and curious mind allows you to see opportunity.
Thank you for sharing this...it connects the big theory/promise of Design Thinking to the Corporate Bottom Line!
- Log in to post comments
Thanks William. Design Thinking has had a big impact at Citrix.
- Log in to post comments
A challenge that any global company faces is how to improve collaboration across timezones and continents. Research and design are so hands on and having "live" interaction between colleagues is incredibly valuable. Sometimes video conferencing isn't realistic due to timezones. Travel budgets don't always allow as much travel as we would like for face-to-face communication. I would love to hear more about how Citrix handles this challenge!
- Log in to post comments
Kathy..this is so true! I wish all our teams were in one location. Life would be much easier, but as you point out this is not the reality. I received a similar question from another reader, so I'll echo some thoughts.....
The technology is great, but what we have found is that there are critical places in a project where technology is not the answer and it is key to bring the primary stakeholders together and to work in low-tech ways. For example, at the kickoff of a project. The power of having face time with teammates to build a team connection; establish goals; and ideate with pen and whiteboard in the beginning of a project is key. We insist on face-to-face time at these kinds of milestones. You can't be together at all times so pick a few points where it matters the most.
When you set this foundation it makes it easy to redistribute across the globe and collaborate remotely. For distributed teams, the combination of high-tech and low-tech solutions along with in-person and remote collaborations are critical to the process. I believe that having the mindset at the beginning of a project helps establish the right approach to problem solving from day 1.
- Log in to post comments
I read the design thinking piece and it tells a nice story. It read like a story, which helped pull me along. My take away is that this revolution in approach at Citrix is taking hold from top to bottom, which is a huge win in any company. The failure to broaden the thinking about how the company has to change to stay relevant has brought down many high-tech companies - they start with a technology advance in functionality, then those same people can't broaden their view. The question is always, "how do we create a new identity that will drive our mission?" Design Thinking broadens the focus of development to beyond a narrow focus on clicks and page refreshes.
I do have one suggestion. As I was reading the story the theme of "we're moving to design thinking" was clear. It starts at this point:
In addition, a new design-thinking branding effort was underway. Spearheaded by Uday Gajendar and Andrew Day, the “Design Matters to Me” program brought news from within Citrix and the wider design community to employees.
But it was not clear what design thinking actually is. There is a brief hint in these paragraphs on myths, which is not where I would have looked for a description:
Myth 1 – Design thinking is only for “design” projects
Design thinking is when you create a thoughtful experience in every customer interaction before, during, and after using your product or service. Everyone at Citrix has a customer, whether another employee, a Citrix partner, an external customer, or an end-user. For any project, starting with empathy is the key to generating ideas and prototyping solutions.
Myth 2. Design thinking is someone else’s job
Creating thoughtful experiences for customers is everyone’s job. Design thinking provides a set of tools and mindsets to embrace customer-centric product- or service-development.
Myth 3. Design thinking takes too long
Design thinking brings a focus on the end-customer and mindsets around collaboration, iteration, and experimentation
How about a section on "What is design thinking?"
My 2 cents.
Joe
- Log in to post comments
Joe….thank you for your great feedback and for calling out the omission of the definition of design thinking.
Design thinking is an approach to innovation that can be applied to all areas of business. Design thinking does not refer to a formal step-by-step process, but to a framework and mindset. It is focused on a bias towards action, a human-centered viewpoint and a mode of continual experimentation. The core idea is that by deeply understanding customer needs, opportunities for innovation will emerge. These ideas can be further refined through rapid prototypes and iterations to result in breakthrough outcomes.
- Log in to post comments
Thanks for this great piece on building design into the culture of an organization! It's a great goal, and a great outcome.
A question I often struggle with in my work is how to engage in collaborative design sessions remotely. How does Citrix balance the need you identified for a purposefully low tech design studio that facilitates face to face interactions with the stated corporate goal of enabling a mobile workstyle? Is a mobile workstyle compatible with design culture?
- Log in to post comments
Kelly, this is a great question. The reality is that in today’s large companies people are spread across geographies and time zones. As a company that promotes mobility and creates mobility and remote collaboration solutions it is critical for Citrix to embrace this reality. There are many wonderful high-tech tools from our company and others to help teams bridge the physical gap.
The technology is great, but what we have found is that there are critical places in a project where technology is not the answer and it is key to bring the primary stakeholders together and to work in low-tech ways. For example, at the kickoff of a project. The power of having face time with teammates to build a team connection; establish goals; and ideate with pen and whiteboard in the beginning of a project is key. When you set this foundation it makes it easy to redistribute across the globe and collaborate remotely with tools such as, video, screen sharing and remote sketching. For distributed teams, the combination of high-tech and low-tech solutions along with in-person and remote collaborations are critical to the process. I believe that having the mindset at the beginning of a project helps establish the right approach to problem solving from day 1.
- Log in to post comments
In addition to incredible products, your approach is producing a loyal and involved workforce dedicated to Citrix and to innovation. Fantastic things develop when you believe that your ideas are valued. Sounds like an awesome place to spend a career.
- Log in to post comments
This is a very inspiring and motivating story that can serve as a blueprint for infusing design thinking within organizations. Its amazing that Citrix has almost made design thinking a social and cultural phenomenon across departmental boundaries. I am sure this infusion will continue to bear awesome results in the years to come.
Perhaps Citrix can provide a social platform/community for design thinking proponents, to help share, learn and evangelize design thinking as a way to propel innovation, creativity and employee satisfaction within any organization.
- Log in to post comments
Arin…I love this idea…we do many things internally to foster a sense of community around design-thinking. From a technology perspective, we have own our social/project management platform called Podio which has been a great tool for fostering visibility, awareness and social participation. People can subscribe and contribute to everything related to design-thinking.
We have also created a Design Matters website where people can learn about the latest and greatest in design-thinking leadership across the company and outside the company. We encourage peple to comment and submit ideas. The intranet is also a great employee hub, so we use that vehicle to highlight stories, news and solicit input through reader comments.
- Log in to post comments
This is a great story. I like a few things in it and have a question.
I like that Catherine is honest about the time and commitment it takes - too often companies under estimate what it will take to implement behavior changes around good design process. I like the mention of senior leadership alignment and engagement all the time. I also like the work on middle managers - these tend to be the toughest.
The question I have is around the present day - I would like to hear learnings around how to take good design process work and break through ideas (coming from design thinking and the catalysts work) and implementing the concepts? Many times the breakthrough ideas are radical or involve new collaborations in the company. How do you keep the innovations alive as the head into implementation?
Great work.
- Log in to post comments
Perry, .thanks for this question. Perhaps naively, we did not realize that this would in fact be the hardest part of the journey…turning design thinking into real results. Here are some things we have done to tackle this challenge. There is a lot…but I think it’s important to share, as it is a critical element of success.
Human-centered design practices are meaningful only if they are implemented. Day Two of our design thinking bootcamp targets implementation head-on: Participants craft an execution plan around a design challenge from their everyday responsibilities. They explore how their project benefits Citrix and Citrix' customers. They create a journey map of the current landscape, noting any current customer pain points and to uncover how needs are served today. As part of the plan, they also create a core team, extended team and identify SME's who they would need to engage. Every project must also have a clear executive sponsor. The plan also shapes their empathy work by identifying analogous and extreme users to target. They end the day with a commitment to taking that crucial first step.
For some, after leaving a workshop they have all the tools they need to run a project. In those cases, we (the business design team) may do "coaching" and periodically check-in with them or give them tips on how to run a brainstorm or test an idea. For other projects, the business design team will facilitate a "design kickoff" and lead the team through 1-3 days of empathy and ideation. In this model, the team then takes the ideas and prototypes, develops them further and works to implement. The most intense engagements are where the business designers work for 6 weeks to 6 months with a team on really gnarly projects. In this case, the empathy work may involve several weeks of interviews and visits in multiple locations. Depending on the problem space, prototyping may be more technical and require more than paper and pen! The longer engagements tend to be projects that run across multiple business units or divisions and are directly challenges to the status quo. These require more "selling" of the project, the empathy findings, the ideas to the business and stakeholders so that everyone keeps aligned and the project team has executive supporters who are removing any roadblocks. We learned from experience that forging a new way of working takes a lot of grit, so having a strong ecosystem of support is key.
In longer engagements, the business design team may be closely involved during execution phase, checking in with the implementation team on a regular cadence to ensure ideas are implemented or the implementation workarounds are aligned with identified design principles. Business Designers' presence as an extended team member during the implementation phase is one of the best ways to ensure ideas are being executed. We can quickly help the team course correct or encourage them to think big when needed.
- Log in to post comments
There are many great points here:
What design thinking really is.
I agree with Joe Dumas’ comment that it’s important to define design thinking, to avoid any misunderstandings derived from using a word like “design” that can be interpreted differently depending on the context. As the article points out, design thinking refers not only to a process, but to mindsets, including adopting a bias towards action, a human-centered viewpoint and a constant experimentation mode.
Appropriating design thinking.
One of the elements that I appreciate the most in Citrix’s approach to design thinking is the development of the 5 principles mentioned here. At times, when organizations attempt to put design thinking into practice, they don’t go past a dogmatic adoption of a rigid process. While at the d.school we might start by teaching design thinking as a process, it is really the adoption of the mindsets of empathy, creativity and experimentation that are transformational and pivotal. Citrix is demonstrating how it is possible to make design thinking a core element of the company’s DNA, through a multi-pronged strategy, hard work and a deep process of self-awareness and reinvention.
Creating a learning organization.
As an educator, I really like the apprenticeship model Citrix has embraced, as this is key to developing an organization that continuously learns. As philosopher Eric Hoffer said: “In times of change, learners inherit the earth, while the learned find themselves beautifully equipped to deal with a world that no longer exists.” This is true of people, but also of organizations.
One related question: there is often a tension between the imperative to innovate and the need for quick results by investors and clients. How do you deal with this at Citrix, given that changing the culture of a company doesn’t happen overnight?
Supporting a wider design thinking movement.
I also appreciate the openness with which Citrix is sharing its learnings around design thinking, not only with other interested companies and organizations, but with the community at large. I’ve had the pleasure to attend a couple of the public events they have organized, supporting initiatives such as the soon-to-be-released PBS documentary “Extreme By Design” and its associated design thinking in K-12 education outreach initiative. Having worked extensively in promoting design thinking in K-12 education, I can’t say enough about the importance of these types of events. They broaden the general public’s awareness regarding the urgent need to transform education - K-12 and beyond - to meet the demands of the 21st century.
Citrix’s products are all about facilitating remote collaboration and changing the way people work. Do you see a way of infusing design thinking mindsets through features in your products, in order to (even more) radically transform the way people work and collaborate?
Physical space affects behavior.
You have described a great design studio space in your Santa Clara headquarters (and more studios to come in other offices). This studio facilitates collaboration across areas of the company and the adoption of design thinking skills and mindsets by employees who have easy access to this space.
Have you seen the behaviors that are fostered by the architecture of the design studio space spill over into other (more traditional) workspaces of the company? You mentioned the experience of the pop-up studio, but do you see employees beyond the business design team transforming their own spaces? And are there any plans to transform other spaces in the company so that the features of the design studio (and the behaviors they promote) permeate to other areas more permanently?
Thanks for an insightful article!
- Log in to post comments
Great questions Leticia!
I think there is sometimes a misconception that innovation will slow things down. Also, that innovation has to be a change that is major in scale. We try to make innovation part of everything we do. We coined a program called “everyday design”…. To help people realize that they can be design-thinking leaders in very small ways…it all counts. You don’t need t o be a part of a team that is creating a brand new product to be an innovator. We also employees to start by asking, how can you simlify or improve your customer’s experience? How can you ensure the experience is delightful, and meets their needs? We also organize Hackdays and Innovaton fairs to give visibility to the design thinking innovations (both big and small) that are happening across the company.
With regards to the question about our products, yes we are always looking for ways to add new features to help people collaborate more effectively. For example, the addition of video (HD Faces) to GoToMeeting has been spectacular, as it really increases engagement of the participants in remote meetings. We also have a number of features in the works that will add a new dimension to ideating remotely. Podio is our social platform that we use the manage projects and collaborate which has been very powerful for distributed teams.
Great question about spaces. The space has had such an impact, not just for the business design team, but for teams across the company. It is regularity used by groups such as IT, HR and Finance. We never would have imagined this when we first brought the concept to life. We have created a program called WorkAnywhere that involves transforming all our workspaces to meet the needs to today’s workforce. Check out this cool video to learn more…. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkxYUt8isiY
- Log in to post comments
Fascinating journey! As the head of user experience research at Android, my team is constantly collaborating across various product areas at Google to create unified experiences for Android users on phones and tablets. I would love to hear how at Citrix you enable and empower cross-company design collaboration? How do you focus various teams on "one" UX vision, and prevent them from getting distracted by product area agendas?
- Log in to post comments
Good point Jhilmil. I think this is a challenge every product organization faces.
One of our values at Citrix is a philosophy of “One Citrix.” Everyone is encouraged to look at the whole, as it is greater than the sum of the parts. This culture sets a great foundation for collaboration across team. But we also have other mechanisms to help support this mindset. One significant support is our creative services team. Their charter is to foster creativity across teams. They also look across teams to seek patterns and trends to help foster sharing and collaboration and to define standards where needed. It is always a challenge to strike a balance between innovation and standardization.
- Log in to post comments
This is an incredible story. I think it takes real insight to identify the myths embedded in the organization which need to be addressed and debunked before the "rehabilitative" work can begin -- having interacted with many Citrites over the last few years at the dschool, I can personally attest to the extent to which these old frames and paradigms have been shattered under Mark's and Catherine's leadership.
The question on my mind is: what *didn't* go well?? Surely it hasn't been an unmitigated success, or without major bumps and misgivings along the way! I know many aspiring design thinkers are eager to hear the stories of resilience and courage that inevitably must form the backbone of such a "success."
- Log in to post comments
You’re right Jeremy….there have been some great lessons learned along the way.
I’ve highlighted some in the story, but one that really stands out is the importance of an executive champion in the early days of developing design leaders. Early in the design-thinking journey we conducted an important project with a part of the organization that had never been exposed to design thinking, but was interested in using the approach to solve a tough problem. The SVP of the group was fully supportive and the core team was eager to try this new approach. The SVP would attend a check-in once a month. We did this primarily so he could first-hand see the value of design thinking in developing an innovation solution. The project was a great success and resulted in a real solution for our customers. We attributed the success entirely to the team.
A short-time later we jumped into another project with the same organization. The SVP was again supportive and this new team was also eager. However, we did not engage the SVP in meetings in this project because he now fully understood the approach from the previous project. What we saw was that the team would get stuck at times…. afraid to push for ideas outside their comfort zone. At times would to revert back to the old way of doing things due to a fear of failure. In hindsight, we realized that the SVP’s engagement in the previous project served two purposes. First, for him to gain a first-hand understanding of design thinking, but second, he encouraged the team at each meeting. He told them how impressed he was with their ideas and encouraged them to push harder. We had completely underestimated the value of these small nudges and words of support from within their organization. In the first project he spent a small number of hours across several months, but that time was invaluable. He did not need to develop the solution or drive the change, but his words of encouragement gave the team “permission to innovate.” So executive support when you are developing your pioneer leaders is key.
- Log in to post comments
This is an outstanding story for *any* company, not just one in the valley. To truly change the DNA of an organization to be design-centered is a herculean task that very few even attempt, let alone advertise as a success story. Kudos to you and your team. The combination of top-down support, grassroots excitement, collaboration environments, and company-wide training are clearly the keys to success, but the scale of executing that at a company of Citrix's size is almost unbelievable. I have a question above and beyond what a few commenters have already asked, however: while the collaboration space you mentioned is a great start, what about extending that to all employee spaces ... workstations, conference rooms, etc.?
- Log in to post comments
Thanks, Eric!
Six additional design spaces have opened and three more are planned to open at Citrix offices around the globe. This demonstrates the company's fiscal and strategic commitment to design thinking. But more interestingly, it was the employees who demanded these spaces. People who had the opportunity to work in one of these space immediately saw the value and self-motivated they led the charge to create one in their locale.
And to your question, it’s not just design collaborations spaces. We have created a program called WorkAnywhere that involves transforming all our workspaces to meet the needs to today’s workforce. Here is quick video that highlights the program: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkxYUt8isiY
- Log in to post comments
This is an inspirational and authentic tale from the trenches of hard-fought, productive organizational evolution. I like how the narrative thoughtfully addresses varied levels within the organization. I echo Perry re middle management work -- kudos. To me, the approach here appears remarkably human-centered and insightful in how the organization itself is addressed. This may be an important point to further emphasize, as many applying Design Thinking can focus mostly on end-users and the offerings ultimately created with them in mind. Empathy closer to home -- for colleagues & stakeholders at all levels in the organization -- is just as essential. There may be an opportunity to underscore this lesson even more. Go, Citrix, go!
- Log in to post comments
Thanks Chris! There is no doubt that internal empathy has been key. Some groups will get design thinking right away and others will take longer. Don’t assume it will be an instant learning experience for all. Have patience and put yourself in the shoes of others who have never experience this approach to problem solving.
- Log in to post comments
Catherine I am very excited about the Design Thinking and everything you've accomplished in Citrix also made the online course at Stanford Venture and read much on the subject.
What things could you advise for a person who wants to implement it in your business or want to start a consulting firm in Design Thinking?
greetings,
Mario Ramirez
Santiago de Chile
- Log in to post comments
Hi Catherine
Perhaps this would be of interest. I am selling my domain name - theCorporateDNA.com and would like to learn if you would be interested to make an offer as this matches your theme of Corporate DNA.
Thanks & Regards
Sanjay
SANJAY BATHEJA
- Log in to post comments
I'm very impressed with this, i just want to say it awesome. Im amazed with the YouTube video the "Why web designing matters to me - using design to make a difference". Its clearly stated in the YouTube video on how really design can make a big difference. All that is explained in the video is true and no doubt about it that its the fact.
Regards,
Maryann Farrugia
Visit Maryann Farrugia Youtube Channel
- Log in to post comments
You need to register in order to submit a comment.