Story:
How to start a movement in your company - Part 3 - Unstoppable
It was back in July 2010. I was planning a large meeting to brief sales leadership on what was coming next and I thought to myself, "how will we know we've arrived?" That's when I started to plan our year-end dinner. I closed my eyes and imagined a small team of us sitting with our leader Bill, smoking cigars and reminiscing. It was the Jesus and the 12 disciples kind of moment I imagined; if we had good stories, then we will have arrived.
I thought back even further in the days of the failed initiatives talking to one of the VP's. He asked me "how do you know transformation is taking place?" Without hesitation I replied, "it's when you start to replace your tribal lore with new stories of behaviors that reflect the transformation. Without stories passed at the water cooler, it's all just Power Point slides." And indeed, during the failures, different leaders had learned to "dress up" all cost-savings projects as transformations. From the top-down, there were pronouncements about the success of transformation. All of the frontline employees snickered, "we do purchase-price variance and engineering cost savings every year. This is not a change." We had slides but no stories.
The initial breakthrough actually came before my initiative began. We were unable to meet customer demand on a certain product and the customer was getting furious. Shiv had asked the business VP if he could shut-down the line for one week to redesign the line into a u-shaped lean cell. Reluctantly, the VP agreed. Shiv and a green-belt named Ray quickly enacted the new balanced cell and instantly doubled output. As director of strategy, I had arranged for Shiv to share his story at the all-hands managers' meeting. We finally had a story that began with the VP saying "this was awesome."
Now a year later, I was leading the Pull Replenishment Initiative and we had stories. For the first time in over 30-years, we successfully implemented an end-to-end enterprise process change. For the first time we demonstrated results with lightning speed, executing projects every 90-days. For the first time, we truly empowered employees to make on the spot changes to their own process without levels of approvals by committee. We were regularly seeing 50 - 80% productivity improvements after every kaizen event. The greatest compliment I received was from Tyler who told me "this is the first time I've ever been asked to use my creativity." By this time, there were so many people working on an opt-in basis on different projects that I actually couldn't keep track of all of them. It was a true "swarm" of initiative by our people and I was riding herd, barely.
So, I decided to push the envelope and announced that we would implement a 1000% increase of volume that we would enable through our pull systems 2-months ahead of schedule. Looking at the company calendar I saw massive disruptions on the horizon and so took the gamble that we could move our project in before several new product introduction projects. I hastily assembled a conference call and gave the warning order: our charter was to move 20 value streams on pull by Dec 31st. We would launch in October.
By now, the team was so confident in themselves that after the initial groans I only heard "o.k. here's what we would have to do to pull the project in." And off they went. We had crafted a scalable template so people instinctively knew their roles and responsibilities. Even though I tried to navigate around distractions, we had several competing priorities with the surge in year-end shipments, inventory reduction programs, and acquisition integration meetings. I spent several weeks briefing every customer service and sales team possible on the implications of our new build-to-order, no expedite model. Everyone was nervous, but agreed to cooperate.
D-Day arrived and almost like clockwork we enabled now 2,600 SKUs on our pull system. In September we had 200 SKU's representing 5% of our overall revenue on pull. In just one month, in October, we increased the volume on our pull system 10x to 50%. On those SKUs we drove down lead-times from 50-days to 14-days and improved on-time-delivery from 70% to 97%. We shipped approximately $XXM of products using the new enterprise process with nary a hickup. We completed a major initiative in 10-months with zero incremental FTE's, no CAPEX, and no consultant spend. In fact, I had spent less the entire year on Starbucks cards and recognitions than we as a company had spent for one day of strategy consultants.
After we finished our Wave 3, Bill invited a small group of us to dinner. It was the scene I had envisioned several months ago, but sadly without the cigars. We ate and talked all night, almost in disbelief at what our company had accomplished. Within 10 months, the number of people working on Pull Replenishment swelled from 10 to almost 1,000 people. Hundreds of participants were purely opting-in. People came up to Shiv and I every week asking "how can I be a part of this?" Our business revenue was down year-over-year but our operating income was up 80%.
Bill raised a glass and said to the team, "in my 35 years in operations, this is one of the best years I've ever experienced." Our resident sensei Shiv cut in "I think the sun, the moon, and the stars all lined up for this one. I don't know if we'll ever see something like this again." It was truly a high point for all of us. The company ended the year paying out the largest bonus since the dot-com bust.
To know that in a down economy people were enjoying the fruits of their labors with our initiative largely contributing to the results was about as satisfying as I could imagine. I have this pet peeve about meaningful work; I believe it's our job as leaders to set our people up for success. It's our job to give them meaningful work, work that excites them, ignites their talents and passions, and produces results.
So, here I am to tell the tale and advocate for good leadership, clear vision, constancy of purpose, and true empowerment. Thanks for reading my story. We're working on Wave 4 right now. I'll let you know the results in a few months.
*******new material! *************************
Based on a con-call we had with Gary Hamel, I have added this supplement to answer some of his questions:
Q: What are the fundamental differences between the top-down approaches that didn't work and your approach?
A: The fundamental difference lies in all the areas we consciously DID NOT try to solve or deal with. Shareholders are not giving extra points to your transformation for thoroughness or completeness. The P&L is a brutally honest scorecard. So, here is a list of items that the analysis showed we should consider dealing with but in fact, due to the need for rapid results left off the table.
Product Proliferation, Sales Compensation, Org. Structure, Performance Management, New Product Introduction Process, Design for Modularity, Global Supplier Dual-Sourcing
We focused on a critical few set of problems and honed in on our "critical X" variables. It turned out that we got 95% of the way home by solving just two: 1) have your component bins full when the order hits 2) get rid of phantom orders, forecasts, and expedites and build first-in-first-out without schedule manipulation. The mechanics of Pull are amazingly simple. The cultural shift was "ginormous."
Q: What innovative approaches did you use?
A: I used an approach called "BASIC - Borrow Aggressively, Shamelessly, Implement, and Combine." Here is a list of those thought leaders who influenced our approach:
Daniel Pink --> motivate through providing independence and meaningful work. Marcus Buckingham --> Focus on who people are, and not on what they are not (strengths based approach). David Petraeus --> Counter-insurgency. Implementing a surge. Winning hearts and minds. Success based approach. Gary Hamel ---> Future of Management, particularly the W.L. Gore story of how project leaders create an "opt-in" model for project teams, thus ensuring the team's success. John Boyd - OODA Loop, how fighter pilots assess data and make decisions faster to win a dogfight. Toyota -- following the Toyota Way will take leaders back to the Gemba, where the action is, and away from Power Point slides. Mike Rother - Learning to See. I could encapsulate my personal journey with that one phrase. King Solomon - to wage war seek many advisors. Bill Schroer's theory on adult education -- The lag between train--do must be max one week. The Heath Brothers - script the moves. Napoleon - l'audace, toujours l'audace.
Q: How did you grow as a leader?
A: Bill forced me to use all influenced-based levers of leadership: leading by example, inspiring others, positive feedback, and recognition. It was very hard to not have the "hard levers" to fall back on like performance appraisals, reporting structures, incentive plans etc., So I learned that the hard levers can be a crutch and if you're not CEO those are very hard to change. It ended up being a blessing in disguise that Bill basically threw me into the deep end and said "I trust you'll figure it out. Call me if you're having problems."
Editor's Note: This is Part Three of a three-part story. Click here for Part One and Part Two.
This is exceptional. Also some incredibly helpful detail about rewarding the right, specific behaviors and tapping into people's motivations. Thank you for writing this.
- Log in to post comments
- Log in to post comments
I work at ADC now Tyco Electronics and I experience this change that David it is talking about and we did a revolution on how to respond to our customers in a 14 day Lt, he inspires that we do not have limits for accomplish our goals .
Thank you David for share this story.
- Log in to post comments
- Log in to post comments
I'm currently part of this important project, I belive it has been a success, if we continue with this, we will continue our ongoing success with our client satistaction and assure a work place for the Mexico operations team.
David you are a great leader, we need more leaders like you.
Regards
Your friend Mario
- Log in to post comments
- Log in to post comments
Great story, David! Very inspiring. Thanks for sharing!
I finally read The Goal last week and was wondering if it might have been a source of inspiration for you.
Keep up the great work!
Nuno
- Log in to post comments
- Log in to post comments
David- Well written story, depicting the sequence of events! Truly inspiring and makes me want to aim higher and higher! For the record, I am the ruthlessly cunning and "can never win a land war in Asia" Shiv that Dave is talking about! I am so privileged to be part of this movement in the company and in the process improvement world! I have been in several organizations over the past 14 years of my professional career, but this assignment and journey has been the best ever!! Why? Apart from what David has decsribed in this story, a truly defining moment came, when I was getting ready to make a presentation at one of our plants, when a lady came up to me and said, "Shiv, you dont know me, but I would like to thank you for the work your team is doing, because I got my bonus this year, thanks to your efforts! Not very many things move me, but this statement really did! and I view this as our team's scorecard and not how many Green Belts, Black Belts you trained, certified etc. We truly live up to our mentor, Bill's philosophy that, "we need to make money and have fun doing it (legally and ethically of course)"! Way to go, team!
- Log in to post comments
- Log in to post comments
Here's how I will compare this initiative. If you haven't watched Tiger Woods (Just think him as one of the greatest golfers of our time) wining those major golf tournaments with his magical and somewhat superhuman shots then it's impossible to portray the real momentum in words. You have to watch with your own eyes and feel the club swings, ball flights, landing on the green and finally how it made it to the cup. With that said, what David did and how he did is phenomenal and even very hard to imagine for average companies out there without going through those defining moments that we all experienced under David’s leadership. It’s just not a matter of making things work rather it matters (to sustain success) how scientifically, healthily and naturally David put the so called Pull Replenishment into a new and dynamic perspective. Obviously, it was a life time experience for me and I am afraid I will ever experience the same joy and thrill somewhere else! Keep raising the bar, David. Remember those 3 things? The present time, the present environment and the people you are currently with. And I think you are the best manipulator of those three things and the proof is our biggest success in pull replenishment.
- Log in to post comments
- Log in to post comments
David,
Great story. I can relate to a lot of this. I am about to embark on centralisation of shared services: something that has failed several times before, consequently mutual trust is lacking. Working in an IT organisation people want to get into the details. I will use the insurgency concept to get some quick wins on the board to start building that trust.
- Log in to post comments
- Log in to post comments
Thanks for sharing this inspiring story. Truly inspiring ....
- Log in to post comments
Inspiring results. It must have been the swift implementation that prevented the stagnant gatekeeper inertia from stopping you. You kept going and enhancing through reward for what worked. You vision was clean and understandable by everyone and that surely helped to get consensus. This has always worked for me, too, but not on such a scale. I am happy that you have documented this for us to live vicariously.
- Log in to post comments
Well written and entertaining story. I gained valuable experience through you; thanks for sharing!
- Log in to post comments
David,
Thanks for letting me know about your inspiring, game-changing accomplishments.
Look forward to hearing more.
Best regards,
Mark
- Log in to post comments
David,
I continue to be amazed at your commitment to excellence, whether in the workplace or in the world.
Thank you,
Barbara
- Log in to post comments
thank you so much for shating your story.. I have learned alot while reading this story..
thanks, David ^^
- Log in to post comments
Great story! Inertia and cynicism are the two worst enemies of change. Kudos for the activation energy necessary to overcome the obstacles, and the clarity of vision to remain steady in the face of uncertainty.
- Log in to post comments
Excellent story David! Thank you for sharing and keep up the good work.
Kind regards,
Aaron
- Log in to post comments
Thanks for sharing your story, Dave. You brought up a lot of great points. I look forward to hearing the results of Wave 4.
- Log in to post comments
Great story, Dave! Hopefully managers from the companies we face similar problems with as the customers are going to read it (and IMPLEMENT) as well :-)
- Log in to post comments
Reading your story inspires me, Dave. Though retired from a different industry, the issues were excruciatingly familiar. Wish we'd had you, your vision, your drive, your empowered people. The principles are similarly appropriate in personal relationships, ie: catch/reward people doing good things, encouraging buy-in, decision-making. Looking forward to next chapter.
- Log in to post comments
I liked the end of your part 3 story:
"I believe it's our job as leaders to set our people up for success. It's our job to give them meaningful work, work that excites them, ignites their talents and passions, and produces results"
It's great to work in a company with leaders such as your self with that set goal in mind. Can't wait for the next challenge.
Best regards,
Juan Muñiz
- Log in to post comments
Dave, you got me excited!
I have been part of a few aggressive & significant transformations, but on the one you led I can't wait to hear more!
When is the book hitting the shelves?
Cheers,
Guillaume R.
- Log in to post comments
David,
Great story - well done!
Cheers,
Friedrich
- Log in to post comments
David! Thanks for sharing this great experience!
Pull Replenishment was a door to exceed all expectative.
Congratulations!
- Log in to post comments
Truly inspiring. I wish i could still be a part of this movement. May be we should use this article as a pre-read materials for all participants in the next wave of Pull all around the globe in the integrated world of ADC-Tyco Electronics.
- Log in to post comments
A GREAT story!!! A real story. A real challenge met with courage, insight and wisdom. Dr. G
- Log in to post comments
Very inspiring.. It actually confirms the fact that anything and every thing is possible with proper strategy and clear goals..
- Log in to post comments
David,
Leadership is both skill and art that you have practiced for years. Well done!
- Log in to post comments
You need to register in order to submit a comment.